Leave a comment

PLANT 34 _Using typological species to solve future water shortages in Manhattan

Munjer Hashim


“Plant 34” is a project which takes on the real-world scenario of drought and future water shortage that is a current issue in New York State and creates a hybrid program which solves the issues conceptually. The project argues that in the future, an increase in population and yearly droughts will place such a strain on the current water reserves, that the need for other sources of water within Manhattan must be established.

The concept:
Due to the distance with which water must travel into Manhattan, placing desalination plants near the Hudson provides the opportunity of bringing industrial infrastructures closer to the user source and therefore provide water to the masses when the reserves are strained or aqueducts are compromised.

Plant 34 1Plant 34 2Plant 34 3

The strategy:
The idea of bringing back the infrastructure into the city may seem counterproductive at first, however, the notion of creating a space that allows people to respond to such anomalies is an exercise on its own.
This brings about a new typology that questions the relocation of these infrastructures away from the urban fabric and their importance within the city. The low salt content of the Hudson River in this location meant that the amount of energy used to desalinate sea water to fresh water would be less. And with the new developments coming into the site, the amount and demand for water will be high due to an increase in the population of the area.
The desalination plant must be able to provide 50 million gallons of water each day for the occupants of the new Hudson Yards development, its surrounding and the people using the terminal.
Due to the small size of the site, the plantation needed to be redesigned and reconfigured to be able to produce fresh potable water daily. Instead of a horizontal plantation, a vertical one is adopted to save space as well as to use gravity to aid in the desalination process, further reducing energy usage.
The composite typology (Terminals + Observatory tower + Desalination plant)
Throughout the discussion of the terminal as a destination the idea raised that this space could become the existential space for all sorts of transportation modes. Buses, rails, subway, cars and the ferry allows the mixture of different modes of movement to be celebrated and therefore the site becomes a space that can cater to everyone’s needs.
A typical ferry terminal is taken first, one with a large pier for ships to dock and unload, followed by a typical and/ ground based terminal, which comprises of a large volume of space with multiple ‘fingers’ which becomes the routes to different transportation modes.
The method used is to fuse two typos which are well known for people to understand what they are and apply ‘rules’, ‘moves’ to them that bring about changes to the typo in both spatial and formal manners.
The typological mix between the terminal and a tower/skyscraper is rather an old form of spatial mixture especially in NY where space is limited and to increase the RFP, the higher you go the better the value of the property. To change the perspective of how a tower is used, it was decided to take the observation or observatory as a specific type of tower which will be fused with the terminal. The thought process being, that the terminal users being from all over NY and the potential of large numbers of tourists, the tower could be conceived as both a destination (landmark) as well as a place of departure (telescopic guide).
This allows the tower to become a beacon through which Hudson Yards gets a new identity. Although the new development is getting plenty of high rises, this tower would be a mega structure, flanking its observatory with other secondary programs such as schools, libraries, retail, office spaces etc. The tower would become the bustling self-sufficient city that NY is striving to be. And its observatory becoming the eye through which its residents can learn from the city and therefore create the opportunity for further development of this neighborhood.
The desalination plant component has characteristics from the tower typology as it is a vertical plant. The towers resemble silos which appear monolithic in nature, however, when functioning, the monoliths transform as ‘flaps’ open to reveal the machine aspect of the project. Through these ‘flaps’ steam jets out to inform the public domain of its function. Providing a performance art aspect to the site through the suspended operable ETFE skin. This skin allows the terminal space to be both enclosed or open air depending on the climatic context.

Plant 34 4

The outcome:
The desalination plant + transportation hub is perceived as an infrastructure that is well known by the people of NY, they are aware of the process by which the water is produced and therefore over time with daily contact with the plant through the terminal space, the project becomes normal to people, part of their everyday. An unknown specie becomes familiarized and a critical part of an urban ecosystem.

Plant 34 5


Who influences you graphically?

My graphics is influenced by a lot of people. The works of Bryan Cantley, Yuri Shwedoff, Alexander Daxboch, Young and Ayata to name a few. I am also fascinated by the graphical layering and intricacies of Sol Lewitt, Zaha Hadid and Daniel Libeskind. There is a sense of exploration and speculation within my admirers works which I find fascination and a great way to converse about design.

Plant 34 6

What defined the graphic language for the proposal?
The project has a lot of different components which as a design decision was meant to remain rather distinct from each other. By making the renderings/scenes realistic but with a hint of fantasy allowed the project to be perceived as a speculation. It allowed the different components to come together and have distinct characteristics without taking away from the kit of parts aspect.


How important is the diagram as a tool for communication?
Architecture is a rather complex conversation which requires simplification to convey intent. The diagram allows these ideas to be conveyed in a simple manner that could be understood easily.
The project uses diagrams in axon and 2D along with 3D renderings to convey ideas and moods. Without diagrams, the idea and process would not be expressed to the viewer.


What is your take on colour?

Colour adds excitement to drawings. If used correctly it can become a focal point. I use color to draw attention to certain aspects of the drawing. It is always contrasted with blacks and greys to subdue the overall effect of the image and try to find a balance.

Plant 34 8

Plant 34 9

Plant 34 10

Plant 34 11

Plant 34 12

What dictated the views through which you reveal the proposal?
Each revelation through drawing is about the moments and experiences it can bring to the viewer through speculation. Therefore, each view is meant to tell a story. Within each story, the views try to express emotions, moods, scale, texture, context, light and shadow. The images try to draw in the viewer and look around the whole image while drawing conclusions and opinions.


Plant 34 13

Plant 34 16

Plant 34 15


Munjer Hashim is a designer, illustrator, theorist who recently graduated with a Bachelors in Architecture from the Gerald D Hines College of Architecture and Design at the University of Houston. His interests lay in the speculation of alternate possibilities and its outcomes as fragments to problem solving. He approaches design as a conversation that triggers emotions and opinions.

Plant 34 17


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s